Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Carter's avatar

With France in flames again, attention is captured by the low-IQ, violent underclass that continental Europe is so determined to import and foster. This leaves the door open to IQ nerds to say, oh the problem is that their immigration policy isn't prioritizing the right kind of immigrant. The Anglosphere countries - for this problem you articulate is not limited to Britain, but shared by all of her daughter colonies - are instead importing an overclass, Brahmins and Han who increasingly displace native sons in positions of status within our own countries.

What Indians such as your millionaire interlocutor fail to notice, and quite deliberately, is that they are given every advantage over natives. Their success is eased by tax breaks, diversity hiring policies, affirmative action in the higher education system. Every single one of them that is advantaged by the state's preferential treatment is simultaneously a native son who has been denied advancement. And of course, once in positions of influence, they bend policy to benefit their own with utter shamelessness. But then, in their own countries they are accustomed to their status being protected by cultural fiat; all their talk of merit is merely flattery for the ears of white liberals.

Would you have been on the dole at all had it not been for these policies? Would the culture of welfare dependence have emerged, had so many jobs not been taken by immigrants? The answer is obvious, I think.

Walter Aske's avatar

Identity is all the things you didn't choose and usually never think about. Anything you can acquire through study is just window-dressing: it's what actors do to take on the role - this is acting, semblance over reality ("For they are actions that a man might play").

I think of From Russia with Love's KGB assassin Red Grant mimicking English customs the better to penetrate British defences. Bond notices a few mistakes, e.g. ordering red wine with fish, but doesn't immediately realise Grant's alien nature. It's only later that all the little discrepancies cohere for him. After all, there are probably eccentric English gents who prefer red wine with fish. We judge identity not as by a checklist, it's more of Wittgenstein's family resemblance model. In any case, it's mostly genetic, all an interloper can do is take on some of the local colouration like a chameleon.

63 more comments...

Ready for more?